- Yorkie Pudz
- Posts
- You're not from New York City...
You're not from New York City...
A rather disappointing bagel.
Alright, week two!
Hope you’re doing well.
Still figuring everything out to be honest with you. There’s A LOT about setting up a newsletter I hadn’t considered, all sorts of boring stuff like banner images (not sorted yet!), logos (not sorted yet!) and social media (have a guess…)
I’m excited to get into it this week, the feature discusses one of my favourite things, the Bagel.
There’s also news from around the region and a nice tele recommendation for you to finish.
See you on the other side!
This week's menu:
Starters
Look, I know she’s moved back down south now but it’d feel wrong not to wish a get well soon to long time Leeds resident Nadiya Hussain. The former Bake Off winner and celebrity cook has recently opened up about her battles with auto-immune diseases. - Link
The Old Vicarage, a Sheffield restaurant in the Michelin guide, has gone into liquidation this week citing the long lasting impact of the pandemic. - Link
The US fried chicken chain Popeyes, fresh off of opening a recent branch in Wakefield, is set to open a drive thru in Gildersome, South Leeds in a few weeks – Link
A York restaurant, Chicchetti Lounge, won the best newcomer award at the Best English Italian awards. They have awards for everything nowadays don’t they? I guess that’s good… - Link
Not specifically local news but certainly one that affects us all: There was a report this week that half of fish and chip shops could close in 2024 due to rising costs with over a thousand already closed this year. Support your favourite chippy if you can! - Link
And finally National Treasure Mary Berry has a new cookbook out now with recipes from her recent BBC show. - Buy it here
Main - We’re Not In New York Anymore
I love a bagel.
I’m talking a real bagel, not one of those soft depressing imitations of a bagel you get from a supermarket that, to heavily paraphrase the Arctic Monkeys, we’re meant to believe were made in New York City when they were made in Rotherham4.
A real bagel; crisp on the outside that opens up into a dense chewy bread that you smother in cream cheese or load with breakfast goodies. You don’t toast it! God no! It’s already the perfect texture inside and if you bake your own or are lucky enough to visit a good bagel shop they’re fresh baked and warm already.
This summer I was in New York for five nights and ate 3 bagels while I was there1.
Before I’d ever been to New York I’ve been trying to learn the secrets of good bagel making2 and that week in the Big Apple was a re-affirmation that bagels are bloody lovely things worth taking the time to perfect.
So imagine my curiosity when a new bagel shop opened at Meadowhall shopping centre in Sheffield, just up the road.
Surely, I thought, in this day and age there’s no way a chain of convenience food stores could have risen to such prominence to have locations across the UK without a quality product.
This is the era of street food, we’re literally over flowing with great food so much so that we’ve had to fit out giant warehouses to fill with all manner of street food vendors peddling wares from around the globe.
And it was with that enthusiasm that I visited Bagel Factory3 in Meadowhall. The enthusiasm soon died.
I knew I wasn’t on to a winner as soon as I walked in. The thin, looking bagels on display were troubling, and the lack of an everything bagel was sacrilege. But maybe I was being too harsh, this was after all a UK chain, they perhaps had reduced the number of bagel types to suit the UK market where your average person on the street wouldn’t even know what an everything bagel was. Have an open mind, I told myself.
I ordered a poppy seed bagel with cream cheese, there was only plain cream cheese but again I pushed this aside as my being overly picky. I couldn’t possibly expect a UK store to stock the same stuff as a New York one.
Then they toasted the bagel without my asking and I knew. Whatever I was about to get it wouldn’t be in the same league as a real New York bagel, it wasn’t even playing the same sport. It wasn’t even going to better the bagels I make at home.
It cost me like £4 so I won’t call it a waste of money. It was worth the £4 just for the curiosity that I’d always feel had I not given it a try. But it was not good.
Just buy a supermarket bagel and toast it yourself when you get home, apply Philadelphia liberally. There, I’ve saved you having to try it, you’ll probably get a better result and you’ll get six for the price of this one.
If you like a supermarket bagel and you’re out and about and absolutely need to get that fix this place will hit that spot for you. But a thin, toasted, supermarket adjacent bagel with a cream cheese that I found personally had an odd taste was just not what I hoped for. I didn’t finish it.
Is the UK so hopelessly adrift at making bagels that this place could pass? Not only pass but succeed? They’ve got over 30 locations! In some of this country’s largest cities! Have we got such little respect for the humble bagel that we’d tolerate, nay, embrace this?
Come on Britain. Sort yourself out.
A not so great photograph of an actually great bagel. Ess-A-Bagel, NYC.
Just buy a supermarket bagel and toast it yourself when you get home.
Sides
That part of the meal you don’t know if you really want but someone ordered it so here it is!
Last week I spoke to you briefly about affiliate links and sponsorships and that all still applies.
This week I wanted to talk about “A.I.”.
I’m not a fan to be frank. If you search “How to start a newsletter?” there’ll be literally dozens of people trying to sell you an online course and almost all of them will tell you that you can support the production of your content using “A.I.”.
Why do I keep quoting “A.I.”? It’s because I refuse to call these things “intelligent”. Ask ChatGPT what 233 multiplied by 444 is. Go ahead I’ll wait. Still confident in its intelligence when it can’t accomplish what a calculator can?
Not only that but all these “A.I.”-‘s are actually doing is a web search that returns more words. They amalgamate stuff they find that’s already been written on a topic into a cohesive blob of vanilla text.
It sounds pretentious but I consider the written word an artistic expression, even when it’s waffling on about a low calibre bagel shop in a shopping centre.
As such I won’t ever be using “A.I.” to generate my content. Everything you see before you is written by an early 30’s bearded man and don’t ever forget it!
As such it takes me a great deal of time and effort to produce every one of these so if I could be cheeky for one moment; if, just for example, you wanted to buy a new air fryer clicking here and buying one wouldn’t hurt. (That does look to be a cracking air fryer to be fair.)
Afters
We’ve recently been watching Ludwig on BBC. It’s pretty good fun if you’re into murder mysteries. David Mitchell plays a neurotic puzzle solver forced into being a detective to find his missing brother with a cast that includes Anna Maxwell Martin and Sophie WIllan.
It’s on BBC iPlayer and it’s definitely worth a watch. Kind of if Mark Corrigan from Peep Show was a detective but rated PG. Haven’t got to the end though so can’t speak to how it wraps everything up. Anybody watching anything good lately?
I’m facing the interesting position next week of having nothing planned to review and very little time to fit something in so we’ll see how that goes.
You might get a feature on what I had for my tea on a weeknight… I don’t know. Anyway, again if you’ve read this you’re one of a select few and I appreciate you. Hopefully you enjoyed it.
See you next time.
Chris
1 The places where Ess-A-Bagel, Liberty Bagels in Manhattan and Utopia Bagels, the order was always an everything bagel with scallion (spring onion) cream cheese which is in my opinion the perfect bagel order. A savoury flavour bomb.
2 Bagels, Schmears and a Nice Piece of Fish by Cathy Burrow has been a huge help in this endeavour. I tried a lot of online recipes but honestly I like Cathy’s New York bagel recipe the best I find it strikes a nice balance between authentic and achievable by a home baker. Cathy also includes a lot of discussion on method which would be helpful for a novice. One ingredient you absolutely will need is Barley Malt Syrup honestly accept no imitations on that front. And finally my home bagel (and pizza, another passion of mine) game really took a step up when I got a baking steel. Home ovens just don’t get to optimal baking temperatures and this gives you a boost.
3 Bagel Factory website… if you’re really interested.